Is it acceptable to negotiate a job offer with a nonprofit organization?

I recently received a job offer from a nonprofit I’m truly passionate about, with a salary range of $57,000 to $67,000. They offered me $63,500, but I’m hoping to negotiate for either $67,000 or at least $65,000. While I don’t have formal professional experience in the nonprofit sector, my volunteer work has equipped me with relevant skills and knowledge.

I have experience in many of the key responsibilities detailed in the job description and believe I can significantly contribute to the organization’s growth, including fundraising efforts. My transferable skills have been highlighted throughout the interview process as a strong asset.

The job also requires me to be in the office 4-5 days a week, although there may be room for negotiation regarding a hybrid work model. Ideally, I’d prefer to be in the office 3-4 days a week and work from home 1-2 days. Of course, I’m willing to be in the office more for special projects if necessary.

I mentioned that for the first 2-3 months, I am prepared to be in the office full-time to familiarize myself with the departments and the role.

In summary, I’d like to secure the maximum offer of $67,000. I am confident in my abilities and incredibly eager to support the organization’s growth, enhance fundraising efforts, and implement strategies to reduce turnover.

TL;DR: I was offered $63,500 for a nonprofit position despite lacking formal experience in the industry. Is it reasonable to negotiate for the maximum salary of $67,000 based on my skills and potential contributions?