You weren’t turned down because you lacked qualifications; you were turned down because someone else was MORE qualified.
I frequently come across posts on subs like r/recruitinghell and r/LinkedInLunatics where people blame HR and recruiters for their rejections. Many candidates apply for jobs or go through interviews and then express frustration when they don’t get the position, as if their experience wasn’t acknowledged.
In my experience, jobs often receive hundreds of applications, many from highly qualified candidates. We can’t hire everyone, and often the decision comes down to minor differences that tip the scales in favor of another candidate.
So, remember, it’s not that you weren’t qualified; it’s just that someone else had a stronger qualification profile.
And regarding the notion that “HR or recruiters rejected me; they must not know what they’re doing,” it’s important to understand that these professionals are often just relaying decisions made by the hiring team. Besides narrowing down candidates for the managers to evaluate, the feedback I provide is based entirely on the hiring team’s conclusions. While I might conduct initial interviews, my notes inform the hiring team’s decisions. I don’t make the final call.
I often find myself defending recruiters and HR whenever I see comments like this on Reddit, but it feels like I’m just asking for a negative reaction.
I don’t have a specific point with this post other than to see if others have experienced similar frustrations (and to vent a bit).
RCadmin
I completely understand your frustration, and I think you make a lot of valid points. The hiring process can be incredibly competitive, and it’s easy for candidates to take rejection personally, especially when they feel qualified. What many don’t realize is that recruitment is about finding the right fit for both the role and the company culture, and that often means that no matter how qualified someone is, there may always be someone whose experience or skills align better with what the hiring team is looking for.
It’s also important to recognize the role of recruiters and HR. They often have to make tough decisions and work within the guidelines set by the hiring managers. It’s not about them not understanding what they’re doing; it’s about narrowing down a pool of applicants based on specific criteria that can sometimes seem arbitrary to an outsider.
I appreciate you standing up for recruiters because it’s a tough job that often goes unrecognized. Candidates should be encouraged to see rejection as a part of the journey, not as a reflection of their worth or potential. Every hiring decision is a complex interplay of skills, experiences, and team dynamics.
Thanks for sharing your perspective! It’s important for a more balanced conversation around this topic.