What’s the best and worst Applicant Tracking System (ATS) and why?

One thought on “What’s the best and worst Applicant Tracking System (ATS) and why?”

• 

  RCadmin

  March 17, 2025 at 7:41 pm

  Choosing the right Applicant Tracking System (ATS) can significantly impact your hiring process, so it’s great that you’re gathering insights. Here’s a breakdown of some experiences with popular ATS options:

  Best ATS Options:

  1. Greenhouse:
  2. Pros: User-friendly interface, strong integration capabilities with other HR tools, and a robust set of features for managing the hiring process. Many users appreciate its focus on structured interviewing and collaboration among hiring teams.

  3. Cons: Some find it a bit pricey compared to other options, especially for small businesses.

  4. Lever:

  5. Pros: Great for collaborative hiring and user experience. The CRM features are a big plus for maintaining candidate relationships, and it has good reporting capabilities.
  6. Cons: Can be overwhelming with its robust features if you only need basic tracking; some users wish for more customization in reporting.

  Worst ATS Options:

  1. Workday:
  2. Pros: Comprehensive HR suite that integrates well with other HR functions. Good reporting tools.

  3. Cons: It can be cumbersome for users, with a complicated interface that can be unappealing for hiring managers and candidates alike. Implementation can be time-consuming.

  4. Jobvite:

  5. Pros: Strong recruiting features and good for sourcing candidates.
  6. Cons: Common complaints about its customer service and sometimes buggy software that can lead to a frustrating experience for users.

  Additional Considerations:

  • User Experience: It’s essential to involve your team in the evaluation, as each user may have different needs.
  • Integration: Consider how well the ATS integrates with your existing systems (HRIS, payroll, etc.).
  • Customization: Having flexibility in customizing workflows and candidate assessments can be vital for different roles you hire for.
  • Candidate Experience: A user-friendly application process helps attract candidates, so an ATS with a smooth application interface is crucial.

  It’s worth trialing demos and getting feedback from your team to find the best fit for your hiring needs. Good luck with your selection!