Navigating an Early Departure of a Hired Candidate

Hello Reddit, we’re seeking your advice on a situation we’re facing. As a recruitment agency, we’ve encountered a challenge with one of our placements: a candidate we hired for a client left before completing her probationary period. The twist? We’ve already received payment from the client for this placement, but they have now closed the job and are looking to hire someone less experienced for a lower salary.

According to our terms of service, we are only required to offer a free replacement during the probation period. However, since we were compensated for the initial hire, we feel conflicted about retaining the payment, especially now that the client is seeking a more affordable option.

We want to approach this situation ethically and maintain a good relationship with our client. What steps can we take to address their needs? Should we consider providing compensation or crediting back part of the payment?

We’re committed to resolving this correctly, but our contract doesn’t specifically address scenarios like this. We would appreciate any insights on how to move forward in a fair manner. Thank you!